Six recent city documents were pictures of paper.
A Bay Area city posts notices, staff reports, and forms every week. We checked its recent PDFs to see which ones a resident who uses a screen reader could actually read.
- Client
- A Bay Area city
- Type
- Document remediation
- Scope
- 14 PDFs posted in 2025 and 2026
- Result
- All 14 fixed and retested
Context and goals
Every resident should be able to read them.
City documents are how residents learn about meetings, permits, and services. Each one should read the same way for everyone.
- Real text and tagsEvery file has real text, tags, and a reading order a screen reader can follow.
- Checked before postingScanned documents are converted to text and checked by hand before they are posted.
- Posted from the sourceDepartments post the original Word file whenever they can, so each one starts out readable.
What we measured
14 PDFs, five checks.
We checked 14 PDFs the city posted in 2025 and 2026 for tags, real text, language, title, and headings.
How many of the 14 files passed each check
- Had real text8 of 14
- Had a title8 of 14
- Tagged6 of 14
- Named its language5 of 14
- Had headings1 of 14
Six of the files were scanned pictures of paper, so a screen reader finds no words at all.
| Document | Pages | Tagged | Real text | Language |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agenda report, December 2025 | 8 | No | No, a scan | No |
| Emergency operations plan, 2025 | 5 | No | No, a scan | No |
| Salary schedules, 2026 | 4 | No | No, a scan | No |
| Annual financial report, 2025 | 310 | Yes | Yes | No |
| Community newsletter, summer 2026 | 5 | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Recruitment flyer, fall 2026 | 1 | Yes | Yes | Yes |
What we found
Most of the files had no tags at all.
- Good news
6 of 14 tagged
Six files were tagged, so some of the city’s templates are already on the right track. Even so, only 1 of the 14 had headings, and only 5 named their language.
- No tags
8 of 14 untagged
8 of the 14 had no accessibility tags at all. Without tags, a screen reader has no headings, no reading order, and no language to follow.
- Scans
6 were pictures of paper
6 of those 8 were scanned pictures of paper, and a screen reader finds no text in them.
One file, marked up
An eight-page staff report for a council meeting, posted as a scan.
- The whole page is a picture of paper. There is no text to select, search, or read aloud.
- There are no tags, so there are no headings, no reading order, and no language.
- Tables are part of the picture too, so their numbers can’t be read, searched, or copied.
Hear the difference
Listen to the same report, before and after.
A resident who uses a screen reader opens the staff report before a council meeting. The voice is eSpeak, the free voice many screen reader users hear every day.
Before
What a screen reader says
Transcript
- “Agenda report, PDF. Document.”
- Silence. The page is a picture, so there is nothing to read.
After
What a screen reader says
Transcript
- “Agenda report, PDF. Document.”
- “Heading level 1, Agenda report.”
- “Heading level 2, Recommendation.”
- “Table with 3 columns and 6 rows.”
- “Item, column 1. Amount, column 2.”
The path to good
Three steps to files everyone can read.
- Convert and tagConvert each scan to real text, check it by hand, then tag it with headings and reading order.
- Post the originalAsk departments to post the original Word file whenever they can, instead of a scan, because it is faster to fix and easier to read.
- Start smallStart with a $750 pilot on one packet, then a retainer for new files.
The result
All 14 files fixed and retested.
We converted the six scans to real text, checked every word by hand, and tagged all 14 files with headings, reading order, and language. Each one passed the PDF/UA check and a hand test with a screen reader.
All case studies are samples. Each is based on our past work or on our audits of publicly available websites, documents, and social media. Names and details have been changed to protect privacy.
Before you buy
We start with a free light audit.
We prepare it for you and send you what we find.
- We check your homepageKeyboard, screen reader, contrast, and zoom.
- We review one public documentTags, headings, image descriptions, and language.
- We fix one public document freeYou get it back fixed, with a before and after.
- We send you what we findA short written summary you can share with your team.