Haven Smith & Company

Our own site, audited to the standard we sell, and passed.

Before we asked anyone to trust our audit, we ran the full A+ Audit on havensmith.company, all 191 pages and every download, and fixed what we found.

Client
Haven Smith & Company
Type
A+ Audit
Scope
191 pages and every PDF
Result
Every page passed

Context and goals

Our site sells books and downloads, collects sign-ups, and books sessions. Visitors use it on phones and desktops, with keyboards, screen readers, and zoom.

The goal was simple. Every page and every file should work for every visitor, and we should be able to prove it.

What success looks like

  • Every page passes the automated WCAG check at desktop and phone widths.
  • Every key task works by keyboard and screen reader: signing up, buying, and booking.
  • Every downloadable PDF passes the PDF/UA check, so screen readers can read it.

What we measured

We tested all 191 pages at desktop and phone widths, ran four key tasks by hand, and checked every download.

The A+ Audit scores five lenses: accessibility, usability, search, performance, and downloads. The site started at 81, a B-minus, with accessibility at 72.

Scores before the fixes, out of 100

  • Accessibility72
  • Usability84
  • Search82
  • Performance84
  • Downloads78
  • Overall81, a B-minus

After the fixes, all 191 pages passed the automated WCAG check at desktop and phone widths.

The ten gaps, in the order we fixed them
GapLensSize of fixStatus
Some sign-up forms failed without a wordAccessibilitySmallFixed
Faded text on two holiday pagesAccessibilitySmallFixed
Product pages had no product data for searchSearchMediumFixed
Most PDFs had no accessibility tagsDownloadsMediumFixed
Phones waited too long for the first big textPerformanceMediumFixed
A button said one thing and did anotherUsabilityTinyFixed
A visual heading was not a real headingAccessibilityTinyFixed
One paragraph was a shade too lightAccessibilityTinyFixed
Small polish itemsSeveralTinyFixed

What we found

  • The good news: there were no true blockers, and every page could be reached by keyboard.
  • 52 color contrast problems across the site.
  • A sign-up form that hid its error messages from screen readers.
  • Downloadable PDFs with no accessibility tags.
  • Heading order and list errors, and one button too small to tap easily.

A one-page holiday card guide, posted as a PDF

One download, marked up

  1. The title looks like a heading, but the file has no tags, so a screen reader can’t find it.
  2. The six steps look like a list, but a screen reader hears one long run of text.
  3. The file never names its language, so a screen reader has to guess how to pronounce it.

After: the tags we add

  • <Document lang="en-US">
  • <H1> The card guide
  • <P> Here is every card in full
  • <L> 6 list items, in order
  • <P> Footer, marked as page decoration

Hear the difference

A visitor mistypes an email address on the sign-up form and presses the button.

Before

What a screen reader says

  1. “Email, edit text, ashleyexample.com.”
  2. “Send my free chapters, button.”
  3. Nothing else. The error message stays hidden, so the visitor thinks it worked.

After

What a screen reader says

  1. “Email, edit text, required, ashleyexample.com.”
  2. “Send my free chapters, button.”
  3. “Please check your email address. It should look like name@example.com.”

The path to good

  • We fixed all ten gaps in the order the report gave them, starting with what blocked people most. The words on the site stayed the same.
  • We rebuilt every PDF with tags, headings, reading order, and language, with the same text and look as before.

Follow-up

After the fixes, all 191 pages passed the automated WCAG check at desktop and phone widths, and every downloadable PDF passed the PDF/UA check.

We measure speed again on the live site, and we retest whenever the site changes.

Take it with you

Download the work.

Both files are tagged and tested for screen readers.

See more

See how other organizations are doing.

See all case studies

Want to see it on your files?

Get a free accessibility check.

Start free