Nonprofits · A+ audit
A nonprofit website, scored and fixed in the right order.
A literacy nonprofit runs its tutor sign-ups, donations, and reading events through its website. It asked for an A+ audit to learn what was stopping people, and what to fix first on a small budget.
- Client
- A literacy nonprofit
- Type
- A+ audit
- Scope
- 120 pages and 3 key tasks
- Result
- From 68 to 93
Context and goals
Volunteers sign up to tutor, donors give online, and families register for free reading events. Many visitors use phones, and some use screen readers, keyboards, or zoom.
The nonprofit had a small budget and wanted to spend it where it would help the most people.
What success looks like
- Every key task works with a keyboard, a screen reader, and zoom: signing up to tutor, giving, and registering for an event.
- Visitors can find what they need and finish what they came to do.
- Pages load quickly on a phone, and people can find the site from a search engine.
What we measured
We tested all 120 pages at desktop and phone widths against WCAG 2.2 AA, ran the 3 key tasks by hand, and scored four lenses: accessibility, usability, site performance, and search.
The site started at 68 overall, with accessibility at 58.
Scores before the fixes, out of 100
- Accessibility58
- Usability71
- Site performance66
- Search77
- Overall68
After the fixes, the site scored 93 overall.
| Gap | Lens | Size of fix | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| The donation form hid its errors | Accessibility | Small | Fixed |
| The volunteer form asked twice | Usability | Small | Fixed |
| 41 contrast problems | Accessibility | Medium | Fixed |
| Large photos slowed phones | Site performance | Small | Fixed |
| Event pages had no search descriptions | Search | Small | Fixed |
What we found
- The good news: the writing was clear and warm, and every page could be reached by keyboard.
- The donation form hid its errors from screen readers.
- The volunteer sign-up asked for the same details twice.
- 41 color contrast problems across the site.
- Large photos made pages slow to load on a phone.
Hear the difference
A donor who uses a screen reader leaves the card number blank and presses the button.
Before
What a screen reader says
- “Give now, button.”
- Nothing else. The error stays hidden, so the donor thinks the gift went through.
After
What a screen reader says
- “Give now, button.”
- “Please enter your card number to finish your gift.”
The path to good
- We gave the nonprofit 12 fixes in order, starting with what blocked people most, with the size of each fix so it could plan its budget.
- Its team made the small fixes. We fixed the donation and sign-up forms and retested each one by hand.
Follow-up
After the fixes, the site scored 93 overall, and all 3 key tasks worked with a keyboard and a screen reader.
All case studies are samples. Each is based on our past work or on our audits of publicly available websites, documents, and social media. Names and details have been changed to protect privacy.
Before you buy
We start with a free light audit.
We prepare it for you and send you what we find.
- We check your homepageKeyboard, screen reader, contrast, and zoom.
- We review one public documentTags, headings, image descriptions, and language.
- We fix one public document freeYou get it back fixed, with a before and after.
- We send you what we findA short written summary you can share with your team.