Research · Research

459 public PDFs from 10 agencies. 79% had at least one barrier.

To see where California agencies really stand before the ADA Title II deadlines, we checked the public PDFs of 10 cities, counties, and school districts.

Client
Ten California agencies
Type
Research
Scope
459 public PDFs
Result
79% had a barrier

Context and goals

Agencies are working toward the Department of Justice deadlines now. We wanted a fair picture of how far along they are, using only what any resident can download.

What success looks like

  • Every file is tagged, has real text, and names its language.
  • Every file gives screen readers headings and image descriptions.

What we measured

We checked 459 public PDFs from 4 cities and counties and 6 school districts, most of them in the Bay Area. Each file was checked for tags, real text, language, title, headings, and image descriptions.

What we found across all 459 files

  • Had real text91%
  • Had at least one barrier79%
  • Never named a language57%
  • Had no tags at all39%
  • Were scanned pictures39 files

Most files can be fixed without retyping a word, because the text is already there.

Every agency we checked
AgencyFilesNo tagsNo languageScansHad a barrier
School district A603737097%
School district B5948531197%
School district C601540477%
School district D431424074%
School district E55926065%
School district F1345362%
City A521429683%
City B592119869%
County A571429668%
County B1111100%
All ten4591772633979%

What we found

  • The good news: more than 90% of the files already had real text, so most can be fixed without retyping a word.
  • 79% of all files had at least one barrier for screen reader users.
  • 57% never told a screen reader which language to read in.
  • 39% had no accessibility tags at all.
  • 39 files were scanned pictures of paper, with no readable text.

What one typical public PDF looked like

The four most common problems

  1. No tags, so a screen reader can’t find headings, lists, or tables.
  2. Images with no description, so a screen reader skips them or reads a file name.
  3. Scanned pages with no real text at all.
  4. No language named, so a screen reader guesses how to pronounce every word.

After: the tags we add

  • <Document lang="en-US">
  • <H1> Document title
  • <Figure alt="Map of the new bike lanes downtown">
  • <P> Real text from the scanned page
  • <Table> Headers announced

The path to good

  • Fix the most-used files first with a deadline sprint, then keep new files clean with a monthly retainer.
  • Check vendor work by hand, because tagged files still failed when nobody reviewed the tags.

Follow-up

Agency names are kept private, and each agency can ask for its own numbers.

All case studies are samples. Each is based on our past work or on our audits of publicly available websites, documents, and social media. Names and details have been changed to protect privacy.

Take it with you

Download the work.

Both files are tagged and tested for screen readers.

Before you buy

We start with a free light audit.

We prepare it for you and send you what we find.

  • We check your homepageKeyboard, screen reader, contrast, and zoom.
  • We review one public documentTags, headings, image descriptions, and language.
  • We fix one public document freeYou get it back fixed, with a before and after.
  • We send you what we findA short written summary you can share with your team.

Start the conversation

No cost and no obligation. We only look at public pages, and we keep your results only as long as the follow-up needs them. You’ll also get occasional deadline updates, and you can unsubscribe anytime.